When comparing home remodeling projects, the key question is simple: which upgrades tend to deliver the best resale value, and which ones are more about personal enjoyment than payback? In general, projects tied to function, visible condition, curb appeal, and broad buyer appeal tend to perform better than highly customized luxury renovations.
That said, homeowners should use ROI as a decision tool, not a guarantee. Even strong projects do not consistently return 100% of their cost, and actual results can vary widely based on the project, market, timing, and scope of work.
A remodel can still be worthwhile even if it does not fully pay for itself at resale. Improvements that enhance safety, comfort, livability, or energy efficiency may still make sense, especially if you plan to enjoy the home before selling. Below is a closer look at common remodeling projects and how to think about their likely ROI.
The best remodeling ROI usually comes from projects that match what buyers already expect in your market and price range. If a home shows visible wear, lacks basic functionality, or falls short of nearby comparable homes, practical updates can do more to protect resale value than expensive custom upgrades.
Project scope matters too. Midrange improvements often make more financial sense than high-end overhauls because over-improving a home can shrink the pool of buyers willing to pay for those extras. ROI can also shift based on whether the work improves daily function, addresses obvious defects, or adds energy-efficiency appeal that buyers can easily understand.
When it comes to remodeling projects, the kitchen is the area that gets most homeowners’ wheels spinning. And with good reason: innovative building materials and modern design sensibilities have transformed the kitchen from a stuffy, utilitarian space into an open and inviting hub sure to rival the most trendy cafés in the city.
However, not all kitchen remodels are created equal when it comes to ROI. In general, more modest kitchen updates tend to make better financial sense than lavish, highly customized overhauls.
Essentially, it is possible to create too much kitchen. When the cost of the kitchen renovation comprises a significant portion of the home’s total value, the returns on the project are likely to be smaller. Therefore, instead of attempting to completely recreate and expand the space, stick with simple projects such as updating the countertops, adding more energy-efficient appliances, and replacing dated cabinets.
After the kitchen, the bathroom is arguably the next most exciting home renovation to perform, as homeowners fantasize about the possibilities of an in-home spa. As with kitchens, midrange bathroom remodels often make more financial sense than upscale projects.
While most statistics suggest that adding an upscale or lavish master bathroom will yield a lower ROI than a modest remodeling project, adding a small ½ bath on the main floor may still improve functionality and buyer appeal.
When looking into the least valuable projects in terms of ROI, bedrooms are at the top of the list. Most bedroom renovations, specifically those performed on the master suite, are viewed more as a luxury than a necessity, with features such as walk-in closets, additional lounging space, and bathrooms with Whirlpool tubs unlikely to be appealing to all buyers. As a result, homeowners should expect these projects to recoup only part of their cost, especially when the scope becomes highly customized.
Even adding more bedrooms is not always highly valuable, with returns varying widely by layout, project scope, and market conditions. When making bedroom additions, homeowners need to be particularly careful about eating into functional space elsewhere, such as through a smaller living room or elimination of a home office area.
However, one way to make a bedroom addition more practical is by converting unused space in the attic or unfinished basement into an extra bedroom, which can add usable living space and improve overall appeal.
The expected ROI on floor replacements can be all over the place. However, the gold standard for home floors is hardwood, with buyers more likely to prefer homes with hardwood floors over any other type of flooring material. Whether solid or engineered hardwood, upgrading to new hardwood floors can help add value and broaden buyer appeal.
The ROI for other flooring materials will be much more modest. Products such as marble, porcelain, and ceramic tile can still add appeal, but installation costs can vary widely depending on the material, labor, and project scope.
Carpet, laminate, and vinyl may still make sense when affordability, durability, or ease of maintenance is the priority, but they typically play more of a supporting role in resale value than standout hardwood upgrades. As with other remodels, buyer expectations and the overall home price point matter.
A roof replacement is not the most luxurious renovation, but it can actually be quite valuable in terms of ROI, as a quality roof will do wonders for a home’s curb appeal and insulation. In general, replacing an aging roof can support resale appeal while also addressing practical concerns such as weather protection and efficiency.
Upgraded roofing products, such as clay or metal tiles, will usually cost more than basic roofing materials, and the financial return will depend on the home, market, and buyer expectations.
One important note on roofing is that the ROI can vary based on region. Metal is more valuable in areas that are hit with heavy snowfall, while ceramics are preferred in hot locations thanks to a higher thermal mass that will not readily transfer ambient heat into the home’s interior.
Window and door replacements are often appealing because they are easier for buyers to notice than many behind-the-scenes upgrades. New windows and doors can improve appearance, help make the home feel more secure and maintained, and support better comfort through a tighter building envelope.
Window replacements can improve comfort, appearance, and efficiency, but returns depend on the product chosen and the local market. Door replacements are even more affordable, with a steel entry door project averaging $2,435 in the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report.
Exterior remodeling projects are sometimes overlooked in the grand scheme of home renovation, but they can be surprisingly simple and highly valuable. In the NAR 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, an overall landscape upgrade was cited as returning 100% of its cost at resale.
Furthermore, outdoor structures such as decks, patios, and porches are attractive features that can strengthen a home’s outdoor living appeal.
Finally, do not forget about the garage. A dented, dated, and unattractive garage door can be severely limiting your home’s curb appeal, and garage door replacement is often cited as a strong-value exterior upgrade.
If you plan to sell soon, prioritize projects that fix visible wear, improve first impressions, and bring the home in line with buyer expectations for the neighborhood. That usually means focusing on practical kitchen and bathroom updates, exterior improvements, roofing when needed, and other repairs that reduce obvious objections.
If you are remodeling mainly for comfort, convenience, or long-term use, a lower resale ROI does not automatically make the project a poor choice. Bedroom suite upgrades, highly personalized finishes, and larger lifestyle renovations may still be worth doing if you expect to stay in the home long enough to enjoy them.
A useful rule of thumb is to match the project to your timeline. Short-term sellers often benefit most from broad-appeal fixes, while longer-term owners have more room to prioritize quality of life over immediate resale payback.
The best home remodeling projects by ROI are usually the ones that improve function, condition, efficiency, and broad buyer appeal without pushing the home beyond what the local market supports. Before committing to a renovation, think about whether your goal is to maximize resale value, improve day-to-day livability, or balance both.
Even projects with strong resale potential still require budget discipline. Before starting, it helps to compare what you can comfortably spend, how long you plan to stay in the home, and whether the remodel is meant to support a sale, long-term use, or the purchase of a fixer-upper.
Depending on your situation, homeowners may look at cash savings, equity-based borrowing, or purchase-and-renovation planning. If financing is part of the decision, it can help to compare payment scenarios and loan options before choosing the scope of work.
Matt Lee is the owner of the Innovative Building Materials blog and a content writer for the building materials industry. He is focused on helping fellow homeowners, contractors, and architects discover materials and methods of construction that save money, improve energy efficiency, and increase property value.
Sammamish Mortgage can help. We serve clients across Washington, Idaho, Colorado, Oregon, and California. Since 1992, we’ve been providing several mortgage programs and products with flexible qualification criteria to borrowers across the Pacific Northwest. Visit our website to get an instant rate quote or to use our online mortgage calculator. Or, reach out to us if you are ready to get pre-approved for a mortgage.
ROI stands for return on investment, measuring how much value a project adds compared to its cost.
Garage door replacement is commonly regarded as a high-value exterior improvement, but the top return can vary by market and project type.
Yes, midrange kitchen remodels can recoup a meaningful portion of their cost, though returns vary by market and project scope.
Bathroom remodels can be a smart investment. In the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, midrange bathroom remodels were described as recouping around 80% of cost.
Deck additions can add outdoor living appeal, but the return depends on the project scope, materials, and local market.
Yes. According to the NAR 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, landscaping can offer over 100% ROI.
Window replacements can add value while also improving comfort and energy efficiency, but returns vary by product and market.
Yes, adding a bathroom can boost resale value, though ROI varies by location and layout.
Yes, improvements like insulation and solar panels can enhance value and reduce utility costs.
Home office additions have lower ROI but may appeal to remote workers.
Targeted upgrades often yield better ROI than full-scale renovations.
Smart tech adds appeal but may not significantly increase resale value.
Our loan officers are ready and waiting to help you apply for your home loan.
Learn more about the people behind Sammamish Mortgage
Whether you’re buying a home or ready to refinance, our professionals can help.
Mortgage Support — 24/7
No Obligation and transparency 24/7. Instantly compare live rates and costs from our network of lenders across the country. Real-time accurate rates and closing costs for a variety of loan programs custom to your specific situation.
Adjust the parameters based on what you want to track
