A home warranty may be worth it for some homeowners, but not for others. If your home has older systems or appliances, or you do not have much set aside for surprise repairs, a warranty may help make costs more predictable. But if you already have builder or manufacturer coverage, or the contract has too many exclusions, it may offer little value. In this article, we’ll look at the pros and cons, where coverage can overlap, and how to decide whether a home warranty is right for you.
Those who own homes might regularly receive mail advertising for a home warranty. Many people end up tossing these leaflets away because they think this is just another form of home insurance, which people often get through their mortgage lender. In reality, a home warranty is not home insurance, and understanding that difference is one of the biggest factors in deciding whether it is worth buying.
A home warranty is a service contract that may help cover the cost to repair or replace certain home systems and appliances if they break down. Similar to insurance, people usually pay an annual premium for coverage, but the contract only applies to listed items and specific situations. If someone needs to file a claim, they can usually do so online or over the phone. Once the claim is filed, a professional or contract repair person may come out, and the homeowner pays a service fee, which works somewhat like a deductible. In some cases, the homeowner will have to pay the entire bill and get reimbursed later.
A home warranty is often confused with other types of coverage, but each one is meant to handle a different kind of problem:
Before buying a home warranty, it is smart to check whether you already have protection through a builder or manufacturer warranty. That can help you avoid paying for duplicate coverage that may not add much value.
One of the main reasons people buy a home warranty is to make repair costs more predictable. Instead of facing the full cost of a covered repair all at once, you may only owe the service fee and any non-covered charges under the contract. That can be especially appealing in older homes, where systems and appliances may be more likely to fail over time. Of course, before you close on a home, you should have it inspected so that you are aware of all issues ahead of time.
Another practical benefit is budgeting. If you are concerned about unexpected home repairs affecting your monthly finances, a warranty may provide some peace of mind by limiting at least part of your out-of-pocket exposure on covered claims. For some homeowners, that predictability is the main value of the plan.
The drawbacks usually come down to the contract details. Home warranties often exclude certain repairs, maintenance-related problems, and conditions that are not covered under the policy terms. That means a homeowner may pay for the plan, file a claim, and still learn that the issue is excluded.
Another concern is claim friction. Many home warranty companies work with specific repair companies, so you may have less control over who does the work and when they can come out. Some plans also require preapproval before repairs are covered, and some reimbursement rules are stricter than homeowners expect.
It is also important to understand that some warranties may favor repair over replacement. Even when an item keeps failing or seems beyond its useful life, the contract may still limit when replacement is approved. In addition, some plans have coverage caps or limits that reduce how much the company will pay toward a claim. In short, the value depends less on the sales pitch and more on the actual terms of the contract.
Whether a home warranty is worth it usually depends on a few fit factors:
In general, a home warranty is often less compelling on a brand new home because some builders may provide limited warranty coverage on certain defects or systems, and some new homes may come with longer protection for major structural defects. For example, the Federal Trade Commission notes that some builders give coverage for up to 10 years for major structural defects, and some state-run programs provide limited ten-year warranty coverage on certain new-home issues. Still, warranty terms and legal requirements are not uniform everywhere, so buyers should review the specific builder warranty and any state protections that apply rather than assume the same rules apply in every state.
Likewise, brand new appliances often come with manufacturer warranties, so a separate home warranty may overlap with protection you already have.
Alternatively, if someone has an older home or older appliances, the home warranty might be worth it. Older appliances are more likely to break down and, thus, require repairs. Therefore, people need to think about their own individual circumstances and weigh the risk of a broken appliance against the cost of the policy. A home warranty may be right for some people but not others.
After weighing the pros and cons, you may decide that a home warranty is worth considering. To choose the right one, compare several companies and read the actual contract terms, not just the marketing summary.
As you shop, compare:
If you do not know where to begin your search or need some guidance along the way, then consider speaking with your mortgage lender. That said, while you are price comparing and policy shopping, it is crucial that you understand the coverage that is available. You should know exactly what will be covered as well as what the fine print says. Ultimately, you need to be clear on what happens when you utilize your home warranty—this includes understanding reimbursement policies in the event you have to pay for the entire repair or the next steps when a broken item cannot be fixed.
Are you currently home shopping and considering financing, home warranties, and more? Are you ready to apply for a mortgage to buy a home? If so, Sammamish Mortgage can help. We are a local mortgage company from Bellevue, Washington, serving the entire state, as well as Oregon, Idaho, and Colorado. We offer many mortgage programs to buyers all over the Pacific Northwest and have been doing so since 1992. Contact us today with any questions you have about mortgages.
A home warranty may be worth it if you have older systems or appliances, want more predictable repair costs, or do not have much savings set aside for unexpected breakdowns. It may be less worthwhile if you already have builder or manufacturer coverage, or if the contract has many exclusions, caps, or reimbursement limits.
They can be worth the money for some homeowners, but the value depends on the contract terms. A lower premium may not help much if the plan excludes the items you care about, limits payouts, or charges service fees that reduce the benefit of filing a claim.
No. A home warranty is generally a service contract for certain covered systems and appliances that break down from normal use, subject to exclusions and service fees. Homeowners insurance typically helps with sudden covered losses such as fire, storms, or other property damage events.
Common downsides include exclusions for certain repairs or maintenance-related problems, limits on what the company will pay, service fees on each claim, and less control over which contractor does the work. Some plans also require preapproval and may favor repair over replacement.
Not necessarily. Home warranties often exclude maintenance-related problems and other issues that fall outside the contract terms. That is why it is important to review the exclusions carefully before buying a plan.
It may be, especially if the HVAC system is older and you want help making repair costs more predictable. But the value still depends on the plan’s exclusions, claim limits, service fees, and whether the contract actually covers the type of HVAC issue that occurs.
Often it is less compelling on a new construction home because builder warranties may already cover some defects or systems for a limited period, and new appliances often come with manufacturer warranties. Checking existing coverage first can help avoid paying for overlapping protection.
Yes, a seller may offer a home warranty as part of the purchase. If that happens, it can change the value calculation for a buyer because the buyer may receive some coverage without paying the full cost directly.
Some home warranties may be transferable, but transfer terms depend on the company and the contract. It is important to review the specific plan documents to see whether transfer is allowed and whether any conditions or fees apply.
Compare which systems and appliances are covered, what exclusions apply, whether there is a waiting period, the service fee for each claim, any item-specific caps or payout limits, whether you must use the company’s contractors, how reimbursement works, and whether the plan tends to repair rather than replace covered items.
Our loan officers are ready and waiting to help you apply for your home loan.
Learn more about the people behind Sammamish Mortgage
Whether you’re buying a home or ready to refinance, our professionals can help.
Mortgage Support — 24/7
No Obligation and transparency 24/7. Instantly compare live rates and costs from our network of lenders across the country. Real-time accurate rates and closing costs for a variety of loan programs custom to your specific situation.
Adjust the parameters based on what you want to track
